Call this a proper debate? oh do grow up

We’re used to pretty poor media coverage of political debates in this country but we’re barely a week into the  EU referendum campaign and  barrels are already being scraped.

‘all the interest, plainly, is in the intellectual and political battle  within the Tory party.’ declared the Sunday Times Leader today, if we needed any clue as to what our diet was going to be from the anti-European press for the next four months.

The Dave vs Boris sideshow may be light entertainment for political geeks and lobby journalists but to misappropriate The Smiths that Joke Isn’t Funny Anymore.

Did the rolling news coverage of Boris’s ‘tussle with his conscience’ rather than his tussle with his hair leave anyone watching feeling more and informed about the forthcoming vote?

I’ve seen more serious discussion in the press about an episode of Keeping up with the Kardashians than this crucial debate.

This referendum is about the future of our country, not the future of a divided Conservative party as Nick Clegg rightly said in the House of Commons.

If standing on a wet and windy high street in Yeovil on the #StrongerIN campaign stall has taught me anything, it’s that the vast majority of people  would rather contemplate their shoelaces than engage me in conversation about their views on the European Union.

Whilst I spoke to a good number of people who were keen to express their support for our campaign and there was the expected “We’re an island” from a few vocal outers they were all outnumbered by the disinterested, the unaware and the apathetic.

If the media continue with framing the debate as old school chums having a disagreement in the tuck shop then it’s hardly surprising we’re seeing the current levels of apathy,

Apart from a few notable exceptions,  the debate about whether we leave or remain in the European Union has  been dominated by old men which makes research by the LSE that Women are almost twice as likely to answer ‘Don’t Know’ in most EU referendum polls. self-fulfilling.

Hardly a day has gone by without another sexagenarian breaking his temporary silence to lecture younger generations that they know best.


Just picking a choice few from both sides of the media coverage, we have been treated to Nigel Lawson, David Steele, Michael Howard, Alan Johnson and Peter Mandelson giving us the benefit of their wisdom. That’s five men with a combined age of 361 given air time whilst at the same time millions of 16 and 17 year olds who will be affected most by the result are denied a vote in this referendum. The Nigel Lawson’s of this world can rest easy that they won’t be around to face the consequences of their misrepresentation.

With the media having a chance to finally present the British public with properly presented debate, if the last week is anything to go by they’ve blown it.

BBC Question Time is probably no longer a good benchmark for sensible debate as the producers seem more intent on developing conflict rather than reasoned argument 

‘I’m so glad we’re having a proper debate!’ Giles Fraser on Question Time on Thursday without spotting the obvious irony that there was no proper debate being presented.

He was joined by Julian Fellowes the creator of Downtown Abbey, himself an unelected member of the House of Lords and a man who makes a living selling shows about an England that hasn’t existed for over a hundred years, chimed in urging the audience to leave the EU over rules “we’ve never voted for”.

We have a long way to go in this debate. 116 more days to be precise.
Adam Boulton wrote in his Sunday Times column

‘The entire UK is being plunged into a referendum it never really wanted..in an attempt to sort out a local difficulty among Conservatives.

 Judging by this week’s media coverage it will be up to those of us who are actively engaged in our communities to inject some reality  into this debate and to work to ensure that the voices of those currently excluded are heard and everyone exercises their right to vote in this referendum.

Nick was right this debate is about the future of our country and not the future of the Conservative party.

For the sake of the millions of ordinary people who will have to live with the outcome it’s up for us to effectively make the case for staying in the EU, online and offline, because the right-wing media definitely won’t.  

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s